Nutrisystem versus Weight Watchers Review: Comparing the Two Diet Programs

Video of the Day

Nutrisystem Vs. Weight Watchers
Jenny Craig also fared well in the study overall. Some articles have YouTube videos embedded in them. Each January, advertisers go crazy promoting diet programs, exercise gadgets, and all manner of health improvement strategies. This is an ad network. Men and women follow the same basic program, except for the number of points allowed for each.

Popular on CBS News

Best diet? Consumer Reports weighs in on Jenny Craig, Weight Watchers, Atkins and more

To provide a better website experience, caloriebee. Please choose which areas of our service you consent to our doing so. For more information on managing or withdrawing consents and how we handle data, visit our Privacy Policy at: Weight Watchers Updated on August 8, New Year, New Goal Each January, advertisers go crazy promoting diet programs, exercise gadgets, and all manner of health improvement strategies.

You get food that is perfectly portioned for weight loss. Weeks two and beyond incorporate more variety. There are currently three plans available, with varying degrees of customization.

With all of the plans, you eat up to six times a day three meals, and three snacks. Reviews about food quality and taste vary. However, what you see is what you get, i. You can eat literally anything you want. Yes, I said anything. Let that sink in for a minute. What is the catch? On program, you are guided to make smarter choices e. Other than that, nothing is off limits. There are multiple tools to help you select your food, including suggested menu plans, Weight Watchers prepackaged food not required, and you pay for it separately , and hundreds of recipes.

Since you are completely in control of food choice, you are also in control of taste, quality, and preparation.

If too much freedom and choice stresses you out, this may not be the program for you. There are always advertised specials running around the start of each year that will bring your cost down. Remember, this does not include any food. With this level, you have the support of your peers, your meeting facilitator, plus online support.

If you stay away from Weight Watchers brand foods, you will be paying no more or less than if you were not on a weight loss program. When you receive your shipment of food, you receive a personalized Daily Tracker, which acts as a food diary. You are also given a Grocery Guide that lists exactly what fresh grocery additions you need.

Since you eat what is provided plus your own fresh produce , theoretically the tracking should be a no-brainer. Keeping track is therefore mostly a reinforcement tool.

Tracking what you eat is a core concept behind the Weight Watchers program. Just the physical habit of honestly recording all of your nutritional intake foods and beverages typically has a restraining effect on most people. Writing down what you eat and drink including bites, nibbles, sips, and chews increases accountability, and becomes a powerful behavior modification technique. Tracking is still involved, since you are allowed a few points to add food off the list.

Nutrisystem offers special programs for vegetarians but not vegans , and for people with diabetes. They also offer separate programs for men and women, and also for people over 60 years of age. It is not suitable for pregnant women, or for people with kidney disease or certain allergies. Weight Watchers has a variation of their program for nursing moms. Diabetics are advised to consult their physician to make any necessary modifications. Vegetarians will find a wide variety of food choices and recipes suitable for them.

Men and women follow the same basic program, except for the number of points allowed for each. Teens can also follow the program. That said, they still promote regular exercise, to the extent you are able. Weight Watchers promotes a healthy level of activity. Lifestyle and Behavior Modification Nutrisystem. The test is whether or not you will be able to maintain your new weight once you are no longer relying on prepackaged foods. Weight Watchers teaches you how to select and prepare nutritionally balanced and properly proportioned meals from day one.

The SmartPoints plan give you full control over what you eat, while guiding you to make the best possible choices. You are taught how to maintain your new weight.

In fact, if you achieve lifetime member status, you will receive free support for the rest of your life. Yes, you can achieve results on Nutrisystem, especially in the short run.

There is limited information on the long-term success rate for people on the Nutrisystem program. Weight Watchers is a solid program, based on scientific research. It has a proven track record. However, it is not magic. You have to actually work at it, and invest the mental, emotional, and physical energy required in order to achieve success.

We've often wondered how those companies' meals-in-a-box compare with each other in terms of taste. And now we know. We joined both programs, obtained menus, and ordered foods. Our tests of a week's worth of food from the companies found that when it came to taste, Jenny Craig edged out Nutrisystem.

But not by a large margin: Jenny Craig's food scored in the high end of the Good range compared with the low end of Good for its rival. To our taste testers, "good" means OK but not great. Our bottom line for taste is that the plans might be worth trying if you're willing to stick with their branded foods.

But you can achieve the same portion control with diet meals and entrées from the supermarket freezer case that may be tastier.

We didn't test Weight Watchers foods because they're not a required part of the program and anyone can buy them in grocery stores. Jenny Craig and Nutrisystem give you meal plans that include their branded foods. The programs have websites where you can track your progress, get tips for diet and exercise, and interact with trained consultants and fellow dieters.

With Jenny Craig, you pay a program fee that entitles you to weekly one-on-one counseling by telephone or at a walk-in center. If you want to continue after your initial program runs out whether or not you've lost the weight , you pay an additional fee. You can pick up your food at the center or have it delivered to your home. Nutrisystem has no walk-in locations but provides optional online and phone support at no additional charge.

Food is delivered to your home. It's the company's most popular option; all of the plan's meals are shelf-stable, which means they don't require refrigeration. The meals were a mixture of frozen and shelf-stable items. We didn't evaluate the cost of the home-supplied items on the plans' menus.

The best diet for you is the one you can stick to. These programs might appeal to people who have trouble with meal planning, have limited time and skill for cooking at home, struggle with portion control, or feel they might benefit from community support and counseling.

If you don't like the restricted choice of the programs, you can devise a homemade version using frozen diet meals from the supermarket. Two experienced sensory testers tasted, in total, 32 Jenny Craig products and 27 Nutrisystem Basic products.

Where possible, we chose similar items. We also conducted a side test of six frozen entrées from Nutrisystem's more expensive Select line.

Jenny Craig edges out rival Nutrisystem